In addition to driving comfort and financial benefits, experts cite three variables that must be weighed against each other when deciding in favor of e-mobility:
1. eco-footprint
The ecological footprint states how sustainably a company behaves in relation to the environment. At first glance, everything speaks in favor of switching to an electric fleet. But if you are really interested in the so-called Eco-Footprint, you also have to calculate whether the ecological footprint is actually reduced by the measures, because as always, the devil is in the details. At the beginning of this journey, most people thought that the calculation was quite simple: take manufacturer consumption, increase it by a factor of X, and that’s it – the reduced footprint. But it’s not that easy. If you want to find out the true values, you have to start with CO2 consumption during production. Even here, there are a wide variety of possibilities: Was the product produced in Germany, the USA or China and transported here? And where was your vehicle’s battery manufactured? Depending on the answer to this question, more CO2 is “produced”. The next topic is electricity consumption. What values are used as a basis? Manufacturer’s data? Results from the ADAC’s Ökotest? And which electricity mix should I assume for my Footprint calculation? It gets even more complicated with hybrids. Here, we still have to differentiate between how much is driven electrically and how much conventionally, and then simulate consumption for both. So if you really want to write valid values in your sustainability report, you have to dive deeper into the subject.
2. costs
Many people seriously want to operate more sustainably. But are the decision-makers also willing to accept higher costs in order to reduce CO2 consumption? Or is the company only willing to reduce CO2 if costs are also reduced or at least remain the same? Both are possible, but with a fleet of several hundred cars, you have to do the math in detail.
3. employee loyalty
Company cars are, in many cases, employee retention tools. Since electric cars/hybrids are trendy for image reasons and also offer tax advantages, these variants are currently extremely sought after by employees. But for now, this has nothing to do with reducing CO2 levels. The suspicion of “greenwashing” is in the air, when there is no serious plan behind the conversion of the vehicle fleet, but the change seems fashionably motivated.
The bottom line is that electromobility is new to everyone – often including the experts. There is not yet enough empirical data on consumption and production. If you are interested in a serious analysis, our e-mobility consultants can help you with advice and calculation tables.